Thursday, 11 December 2014

Unit 20.1: 'Goodbye Afganistan' Analysis


My Observation of ‘Our War – Goodbye Afghanistan’

The first observation that I conducted of the Afghanistan documentary was of a close-up of a soldier preparing for war. This creates a sense of feeling of depression as if you are actually meeting this person first-hand. The second time that I encountered this was when I saw a first person depiction of a war in Afghanistan with narration voice-over. This was a combination of perspective and sound, and I felt compelled to watch onwards because this is a prime example of the effects.

I also heard some diegetic sound of bullets firing. This was applied to make the viewer feel morbid and depressed and sorry for the soldiers in combat. The narration of the voice over gives a blunt in-sight as to what the soldiers are feeling and experiencing.

I noticed some jump-cut editing that linked one scene to another. This is done to make the documentary feel more fast-paced and to speed up the power and emotion of the film. The interview was most of the time foreshadowing what we were about to see in archive footage.

Even thought the soldier had already told us what was about to happen, we were still taken aback to graphic nature of the voice-over and the combination of diegetic and non-diegetic sound created a truly distressing piece of film.

The close-ups of the soldiers faces created negative emotions because we became concerned for their safety, due to having seen a soldier in third person, and were hoping that none of them were going to be hurt or killed. 

The sights of the conditions of the army base, with an expressive description, gives an in sight as to how different and privileged our lives really are here in Britain. The voice-overs are very good at telling us how to feel when watching a specific scene and can generate a whole range of various emotions.

The uncensored swearing, mixed with the melancholy sound of traditional military music, created a plethora of sympathy and empathy for the soldiers, as we could see why the soldiers were so aggravated and that they were so determined to win.  The medical troop yelling at the other soldiers in first person perspective makes me feel sympathy towards the soldiers in battle, because they are battling, despite fearing that they could be next.

The FOW footage of the soldier’s mother mourning his son’s death with the other soldiers in his group, with the narrative voice-over, makes you feel sympathy towards the mother, because she has out-lived her child.

This scene I feel most of all emphasises the effectiveness of the perspective, sound, editing and cinematography techniques that I have learned today.




No comments:

Post a Comment